| Trilogy
motors, actuators and our Linear Encoder Module occasionally must
operate in applications with extreme temperature changes. One such
application prompted us to perform testing on a T2S actuator with
an ambient temperature range from -25oC to +75oC.
|
|
Application Description
A
manufacturer of specialty sensors required an XY actuator operating
inside a thermal test chamber. The temperature would range from
-25oC to +75oC during the testing. Humidity would also go to 90%
relative humidity, non-condensing. Testing was performed prior to
undertaking the project to identify any potential design or operating
problems arising from these severe conditions.
|
|
Test Setup
A
standard Trilogy actuator, T2SS16-2NCTS, was selected for the testing.
Trilogy doesn't have an environmental chamber so we had to create
our own. We used our oven for the high temperature and ice chests
filled with dry ice for the cold temperature. Dry ice temperature
is -78.5oC. Measurement of the internal actuator temperature was
performed every 10-15 minutes using an infrared temperature gun.
The actuator was placed in the oven and run at 30 ips over the full
travel with no load for a period of 4 hours. Actuator hot temperatures
ranged from +85oC to +105oC due to difficulty regulating the oven
temperature. Actuator cold temperatures remain fairly constant at
-25oC. Testing went from hot for 4 hours, cold for 8 hours and hot
again for 8 hours. The actuator was running the entire time. Large
amounts of frost built up on the actuator during the cold running
but did not affect the operation. Following the cold testing, the
frost thawed and covered the actuator with water. Again the actuator
running was not affected. The picture below shows the actuator covered
in ice and frost after it was removed from the ice chests and dry
ice.
|
T2SS Actuator
at -250C
|
|
Test
Conclusions
Actuator Base
Material
The base material
chosen for the actuator was steel. With a 100oC temperature range,
the thermal growth of the base, bearing rail, and magnet track would
be substantial. Each material has its own Thermal Coefficient of
Expansion. Steel has a thermal coefficient of 6.0x10-6 in/in/oF.
Aluminum has a thermal coefficient of 13.3x10-6 in/in/oF, more than
double that of steel. The actual change of length due to temperature
may be easily calculated. Multiply the Coefficient of Thermal Expansion
times the original length times the temperature range in oF. With
a temperature range of 100oC or 180oF, the growth of the 16.8"
length actuator steel base plate is 6.0x10-6 in/in/ oF x 16.8"
x 180 oF = 0.018". Longer bases would of course growth proportionately.
If the base were made of aluminum, the 16.8" base would grow
0.040". Noting that the bearing rail and magnet tracks are
steel, the differential growth with an aluminum base plate would
amount to 0.022". The result would be distortion or even shearing
of screws as the two materials grew at different rates. Therefore,
when actuators experience wide temperature swings, the base should
be steel to match the thermal growth of the bearing and magnet track.
|
| Modular
Magnet Tracks Modular magnet tracks are ideal for high temperature
swings even in applications using aluminum bases. Because modular
tracks are short, each section only grows a small amount and doesn't
apply significant stress to the base. There is also a small gap between
each modular track providing some room to absorb any thermal growth
that does occur. |
| Linear
Encoder Module, LEM The LEM uses a proprietary temperature compensation
scheme to prevent signal drift with temperature changes. Without excellent
compensation, the accuracy, repeatability and smoothness of the actuator
would be negatively impacted. Over the entire temperature range the
actuator demonstrated consistent smoothness as measured by the servo
following error. Accuracy and repeatability could not be measured
while testing. The LEM requires an initial factory calibration step
to achieve its high accuracy, repeatability and smoothness. This requires
stability of the analog signals in the LEM head. By maintaining it's
smoothness and following error during the wide temperature swings,
the stability of the LEM head's signals was demonstrated. |
| High
Flex Cable High flex cable is used in all Trilogy actuators. The outer
jacket is constructed of flexible PVC that has a temperature rating
of 105oC. The lower limit for the PVC jacket is -32oC and remained
flexible inside the cable track during and after testing. The high
temperature was surpassed at times in the testing with internal temperatures
sometimes reaching over 125oC for short periods of time. Physical
inspection of the cable showed no visible degradation after exposure
to this high temperature.
|
| Coil
Assembly The coil assembly has a thermostat that triggers at about
90oC. During testing, the thermostat triggered, shutdown the actuator
and had to be jumpered out for the remainder of the high temperature
testing. The actual coil temperature is rated for 125oC and it reached
this temperature at different times during testing. A physical inspection
of the coil following testing revealed no heat damage to the epoxy
encapsulant |